AWS European Sovereign Cloud: Data Sovereignty Under Scrutiny

Sovereignty's Legal and Technical Hurdles

The AWS European Sovereign Cloud launch presents a compelling offering, but the article meticulously highlights the critical legal and technical limitations that undermine its promise of true data sovereignty. The core issue revolves around the US CLOUD Act and FISA, which grant the US government access to data held by US-based companies, regardless of where that data resides. While AWS has invested heavily in physical and logical separation, including a new German parent company and EU-resident operations, these measures may not be sufficient to fully shield data from US government requests. The article correctly points out that the parent company's vulnerability to US legal jurisdiction poses a significant risk, and that even the technical isolation can be bypassed or circumvented. Furthermore, the article raises important questions about potential backdoors, remote control mechanisms, and the overall trustworthiness of the software stack, which could further compromise data security.

Key Points

• AWS launched its European Sovereign Cloud to address European regulatory requirements and geopolitical concerns about US data access.
• Despite technical isolation, the cloud's ability to protect against US government data requests is questionable due to US legal jurisdiction.
• The article highlights concerns about the CLOUD Act and FISA, which could allow US authorities to access data.
• Practitioners raise questions about remote intervention and the trustworthiness of the software stack.
• The offering is not a complete solution for true data sovereignty, as US law can still apply to the provider.

---

📖 Source: AWS Launches European Sovereign Cloud amid Questions about U.S. Legal Jurisdiction